My last post was about a researcher who manages to produce nothing but positive findings with the least promising alternative therapy, homeopathy. Some might think that this is an isolated case or an anomaly – but they would be wrong. I have previously published about researchers who have done very similar things with homeopathy or other unlikely therapies. Examples include:
But there are many more, and I will carry on highlighting their remarkable work. For example, the research of a German group headed by Prof Gustav Dobos, one of the most prolific investigator in alternative medicine at present.
For my evaluation, I conducted a Medline search of the last 10 of Dobos’ published articles and excluded those not assessing the effectiveness of alternative therapies such as surveys, comments, etc. Here they are with their respective conclusions and publication dates:
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW COMPARING DIFFERENT YOGA STYLES (2016)
RCTs with different yoga styles do not differ in their odds of reaching positive conclusions. Given that most RCTs were positive, the choice of an individual yoga style can be based on personal preferences and availability.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF YOGA FOR WEIGHT LOSS (2016)
Despite methodological drawbacks, yoga can be preliminarily considered a safe and effective intervention to reduce body mass index in overweight or obese individuals.
REVIEW OF INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE IN GYNAECOLOGICAL ONCOLOGY (2016)
…there is published, positive level I evidence for a number of CAM treatment forms.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF MINDFULNESS FOR PSYCHOSES (2016)
Mindfulness- and acceptance-based interventions can be recommended as an additional treatment for patients with psychosis.
RCT OF CABBAGE LEAF WRAPS FOR OSTEOARTHOSIS (2016)
Cabbage leaf wraps are more effective for knee osteoarthritis than usual care, but not compared with diclofenac gel. Therefore, they might be recommended for patients with osteoarthritis of the knee.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF HERBAL MEDICINES FOR COUGH (2015)
This review found strong evidence for A. paniculata and ivy/primrose/thyme-based preparations and moderate evidence for P. sidoides being significantly superior to placebo in alleviating the frequency and severity of patients’ cough symptoms. Additional research, including other herbal treatments, is needed in this area.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF DIETARY APPROACHES FOR METABOLIC SYNDROME (2016)
Dietary approaches should mainly be tried to reduce macronutrients and enrich functional food components such as vitamins, flavonoids, and unsaturated fatty acids. People with Metabolic Syndrome will benefit most by combining weight loss and anti-inflammatory nutrients.
SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF MIND BODY MEDICINE FOR CORONARY HEART DISEASE (2015)
In patients with CHD, MBM programs can lessen the occurrence of cardiac events, reduce atherosclerosis, and lower systolic blood pressure, but they do not reduce mortality. They can be used as a complement to conventional rehabilitation programs.
CRANIOSACRAL THERAPY (CST) FOR BACK PAIN (2016)
CST was both specifically effective and safe in reducing neck pain intensity and may improve functional disability and the quality of life up to 3 months after intervention.
REVIEW OF INTEGRATED MEDICINE FOR BREAST CANCER (2015)
Study data have shown that therapy- and disease-related side effects can be reduced using the methods of integrative medicine. Reported benefits include improving patients’ wellbeing and quality of life, reducing stress, and improving patients’ mood, sleeping patterns and capacity to cope with disease.
Dobos seems to be an ‘all-rounder’ whose research tackles a wide range of alternative treatments. That is perhaps unremarkable – but what I do find remarkable is the impression that, whatever he researches, the results turn out to be pretty positive. This might imply one of two things, in my view:
- all alternative therapies are effective,
- the ‘Trustworthiness Index’ of Prof Dobos is unusual.
I let my readers chose which possibility they deem to be more likely.
“SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF MINDFULNESS FOR PSYCHOSES”
Psychosis is the very textbook definition of “possesses all the self-awareness of a housebrick”; a denotation that easily extends to Dobos and his fellow auto-defalcators too. Honestly, that
incoherent publication listexplosion in a Stupid factory could well be taken for delusional ideation itself. And it’s all fun and profit too, until someone loses a life.
These studies will nonetheless be presented as evidence to those that will not check sources. As a marketing tool they are very effective and convincing to those with a preexisting bias. Unfortunately these studies are also effective at degrading any respect for real science.
important point; thanks
Nothing to do with this post.
I have just listened to EE on Radio 4’s “Why I Changed My Mind”.
The man deserves a Nobel Prize for Critical Thinking.