This paper discussed the potential for collaboration of Rongoā Māori, the Indigenous healing practices of Māori, with New Zealand’s contemporary healthcare system. It aims to bridge the gap between Rongoā Māori and Western medicine by exploring the perspectives of practitioners from both fields, identifying barriers to integration, and highlighting potential areas for collaboration.
Qualitative interviews were conducted with both Rongoā practitioners and Western surgeons. The data collected were subjected to thematic analysis to extract key themes related to the integration process, challenges faced, and the potential for mutual recognition and respect between the two healing paradigms.
The study reveals a deep respect for Rongoā Māori among Western surgeons but identifies significant systemic barriers that impede its integration. These include bureaucratic challenges and the absence of clear referral pathways. Rongoā practitioners express concerns over being overlooked within the healthcare system and highlight a lack of awareness among healthcare professionals about their practices. Despite these challenges, there is a shared interest in collaborative approaches to healthcare that respect and incorporate Rongoā Māori.
The authors concluded that their findings underscore the need for systemic changes to facilitate the integration of Rongoā Māori into mainstream healthcare, including the development of clear referral pathways and initiatives to raise awareness among healthcare professionals. The study highlights the need for a more collaborative healthcare approach that values the contributions of Rongoā Māori, aiming to improve patient care through holistic practices.
The authors also stated that Rongoā Māori, the Indigenous healing system of Māori, encompasses a holistic approach to health that acknowledges the complex interplay of cultural values, connection to wairua, tinana, tikanga, whakaora, whānau, and whenua. Despite its comprehensive approach to health and well-being, Rongoā Māori remains largely marginalized within New Zealand’s mainstream healthcare system.
I beg to differ!
A ‘healing system’ – no matter what its origin or tradition might be – does not need to be adopted into current healthcare because it is ‘holistic’ or because it ‘acknowledges the complex interplay of cultural values’. It must be considered for integration once it has been shown to be effective and safe, i.e. if it demonstrably generates more good than harm.
And has Rongoā Māori been shown to fulfill these criteria?
No!
In this case, please do the research. Until compelling evidence is available, do me a favour and stop the BS!
Every country seems to need its nationalist quacks. Chinese medicine, Ayurveda, “New Germanic Medicine” Maori medicine,
It’s unfortunate that so many people fall for these profiteers, and it’s bad that it’s often politically supported.
The proponents of traditional forms of medicine usually ignore two aspects:
1. Medicine had to be developed in ALL cultures for the same reasons: always and everywhere because of threatening conditions that endangered life or the ability to live: serious injuries, severe pain, dangerous birth complications. Severe shortness of breath, unconsciousness, heart attack, stroke. Persistent diarrhea, insatiable vomiting. Typhoid, cholera, tuberculosis, leprosy, plague, smallpox, rabies. Sleeping sickness, malaria, trachoma, sexually transmitted diseases. Heart failure, hepatitis, gout, kidney failure, cancer.
2. All traditional medicine – including Ayurveda, TCM or Maori medicine – inevitably had to fail in these tasks due to a lack of knowledge and the methods and means based on knowledge.
Anyone who promotes such forms of medicine because of their cultural connotations must admit that these forms can only exist today under the protective umbrella of scientific medicine, and this always only in a secondary capacity, for minor ailments or for preventive measures.