This ‘nationwide, population-based ‘cohort study’ was meant to investigate the probable effect of TCM to decrease the fracture rate. Its authors identified cases with osteoporosis and selected a comparison group that was frequency-matched according to sex, age (per 5 years), diagnosis year of osteoporosis, and index year. The difference between the two groups in the development of fracture was estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method and the log-rank test.

After inserting age, gender, urbanization level, and comorbidities into the Cox’s proportional hazard model, patients who used TCM had a lower hazard ratio (HR) of fracture compared to the non-TCM user group. The Kaplan-Meier curves showed that osteoporosis patients who used TCM had a lower incidence of fracture events than those who did not. Our study also demonstrated that the longer the TCM use, the lesser the fracture rate.

The authors concluded that their study showed that TCM might have a positive impact on the prevention of osteoporotic fracture.

The authors also mention three weaknesses of their study:

  • Firstly, we were unable to include medicines taken at the patient’s own expense. According to the specification of the NHI program, Western medicine for osteoporosis can only be applied after a fracture occurred. It is possible that the patients source such medicines at their own expense when they were diagnosed with osteoporosis before a fracture happens.
  • Secondly, some data related to fractures, such as a patient’s exercise, lifestyle, BMI, alcohol, and cigarette use is not available from the NHI program.
  • Thirdly, the Kaplan–Meier curve might be influenced by economic levels and patient severity. However, we can conclude that TCM might have a positive impact on the prevention of osteoporotic fracture…

Disregarding these limitations, they nevertheless state that their study not only reveals the preventative value of TCM use for patients with osteoporosis in the clinical setting, but also provides valuable information regarding the most common prescriptions provided to osteoporotic patients.

So, is there a causal link between TCM and osteoporosis?

Yes, it is possible.

But is it proven?


Is it likely?


By far the most plausible explanation of the findings is that the two groups that were compared here were not comparable in many ways that affect the osteoporosis-risk.

Major risk factors of osteoporosis include:

  • Inadequate nutritional absorption
  • Lack of physical activity or fall risk
  • Weight loss
  • Cigarette smoking
  • Alcohol consumption
  • Air pollution
  • Stress

I suggest therefore that this study shows that the two populations differed regarding these risk factors.

I also suggest that researchers of SCAM might benefit from a minimum of critical thinking.

I furthermore suggest that, if SCAM-fans want to test whether causal effects exist, they use controlled clinical trials rather than cohort or case-control studies

Lastly, I suggest that authors, journal editors, reviewers and funders (this study was funded by the ‘Taiwan Ministry of Health and Welfare Clinical Trial Center’) remind themselves that they have a responsibility and thus avoid misleading the public.

2 Responses to TCM prevents osteoporosis? No, almost certainly not!

  • Another osteoporotic risk factor you did not list is that increased thoracic hyperkyphosis and the postural forces it generates are strongly suggested to be responsible for initiation of osteoporotic spinal deformity in elderly subjects. The management of this risk factor is of great concern to chiropractors and physiotherapists interested in structural rehabilitation of the sagittal curves of the spine.

  • No doubt the following Dr will be labelled a SCAM on this forum. However, the only person that matters is the patient who decides to take action based on similar suggestions and whether they experience any positive benefits – placebo or real. Some (not all) Academics are too hung up on so called ‘evidence’ or ‘proof’ in the form of published, peer-reviewed clinical trials. The Public are not aware that clinical trials can demonstrate anywhere between low or no improvement and virtually 100% success for any given conventional (non-alternative) medical treatment or therapy. There is no harm in eating whole foods that contain bone-supporting nutrition. Dr Axe could also have mentioned Selenium, Boron and Vitamin K2 (MK7) in his review. Otherwise a useful guide for the lay person;

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

If you want to be able to edit your comment for five minutes after you first submit it, you will need to tick the box: “Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.”
Recent Comments

Note that comments can be edited for up to five minutes after they are first submitted but you must tick the box: “Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.”

The most recent comments from all posts can be seen here.