Charles has a well-documented weakness for so-called alternative medicine (SCAM) – not just any SCAM but predominantly the type of SCAM that is both implausible and ineffective. Therefore, nobody can be all that surprised to read in THE TIMES that he has decided to use SCAM for helping women who have difficulties getting pregnant.
If one really wanted to employ SCAM for this aim one is spoilt for choice. In fact, there are only few SCAMs that don’t claim to be useful for this purpose.
A recent review, for instance, suggested that some supplements might be helpful. Other authors advocate SCAMs such as acupuncture, moxibustion, Chinese herbal medicine, psychological intervention, biosimilar electrical stimulation, homeopathy, or hyperbaric oxygen therapy.
Yes, I know! The evidence for these treatments is lousy, and I would never issue a recommendation based on such flimsy evidence.
Yet, the SCAM project at Dumfries House, the Scottish stately home Charles restored in 2007, offers acupuncture, reflexology, massage, yoga, and hypnotherapy for infertile women.
REFLEXOLOGY for female infertility?
Reflexology, also called zone therapy, is a manual treatment where pressure is applied usually to the sole of the patient’s foot and sometimes also to other areas such as the hands or ears. According to its proponents, foot reflexology is more than a simple foot massage that makes no therapeutic claims beyond relaxation. It is based on the idea that the human body is divided into 10 zones each of which is represented on the sole of the foot. Reflexologists employ maps of the sole of the foot where the body’s organs are depicted. By massaging specific zones which are assumed to be connected to specific organs, reflexologists believe to positively influence the function of these organs. While reflexology is mostly used as a therapy, some therapists also claim they can diagnose health problems through feeling tender or gritty areas on the sole of the foot which, they claim, correspond to specific organs.
Reflexology is not merely implausible as a treatment for infertility, it also boasts of some fairly rigorous trial evidence. A clinical trial (perhaps even the most rigorous of all the trials of SCAM for female fertility problems) testing whether foot reflexology might have a positive effect on the induction of ovulation stated that “the results suggest that any effect on ovulation would not be clinically relevant”.
So, as so often before in the realm of SCAM, Charles has demonstrated that his lack of critical thinking leads him to the least promising options.
Well done, Your Majesty!
4 Responses to King Charles: reflexology to help women getting pregnant?
Leave a Reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
At least the article is balanced in that it reports the failure of the King’s previous dabbling in matters of which he has no proper understanding.
If only, as a Fellow of the Royal Society, the King would try to emulate his predecessor and namesake Charles II who was the Patron and a foundation influence on the RS – founded to promote science and understanding, not whim and whimsy.
Charles III will be known as Charles the Charlatan.
And I note the lady running this programme at Dumfries House is named Meaghan!
Whatever one can say about Charlie the Charlatan, he is keeping tradition alive:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_touch
If only he would study and take up Reiki at Masters II level, (as practised at some centres he supports) – he could send his ‘healing energy’ around the world, and wouldn’t have to touch anyone!
I had long understood that something more than pressing the feet would be necessary, for pregnancy to occur. But perhaps I am wrong…….